Society of Mary Knew of Allegations Against Convicted Priest 20 Years Ago

By Lions Roar Aotearoa Investigative Desk

CHRISTCHURCH, NEW ZEALAND (Wednesday, January 28, 2026) — An explosive RNZ investigation has revealed that the Society of Mary was made aware of sexual abuse allegations against Friar Rowan Donoghue nearly two decades before his recent conviction, yet he was placed on a “safety plan” rather than being reported to the police by the organization.

Donoghue recently pleaded guilty to six charges of sexual abuse involving four boys who were boarders at St Bede’s College between 1996 and 2000. The charges include indecent assault and sexual violation.

⚠️ The 2007 Anonymous Complaint

The Society of Mary confirmed to RNZ that they received an anonymous complaint of a sexual nature against Donoghue in 2007.

The Response: The religious group claims they tried to investigate but could not verify the details because the complaint was anonymous.
The “Safety Plan”: Despite being unable to “verify” the claims, the Society determined Donoghue should be removed from public ministry and placed under a “safety plan” that has remained in effect until his recent arrest.
Police Notification: The Society admits they did not contact the police themselves in 2007, stating instead that the anonymous whistleblower was “encouraged to contact the police.”

📉 Timeline: A History of Silence?

Years	Location	Events
1982–1992	St Patrick’s Silverstream	Donoghue on staff; school says no complaints were known.
1996–2000	St Bede’s College	The Offending: Sexual abuse of four young boarders occurs.
2007	Society of Mary	Anonymous sexual abuse complaint received; Donoghue put on “safety plan.”
Early 2023	Police Dept	Authorities contacted regarding the St Bede’s abuse.
Jan 2026	Court	Donoghue pleads guilty to six charges; name suppression lifted.

🏫 Schools Respond to Revelations

The fallout has sent shockwaves through the prestigious Catholic schools where Donoghue worked.

St Bede’s College: Rector Jon McDowall stated the school was “formally notified” by police in 2023 and has worked openly with them. He emphasized that the school’s focus is on providing a safe environment for current and past students.
St Patrick’s Silverstream: Rector Rob Ferreira confirmed the school had not been made aware of any abuse allegations during Donoghue’s ten-year tenure there (1982–1992) and had not received any police inquiries.

🙏 An Apology to Survivors

A spokesperson for the Society of Mary expressed “deep regret” for the harm caused.

“Our first thoughts are with those who came forward and described what happened to them. We extend our apologies to them and will seek to do so personally at an appropriate time.”

The Society maintains they were unaware of the specific allegations Donoghue pleaded guilty to until police laid charges last year.

🆘 Where to Get Help

If you have been affected by this story or have information regarding historical abuse, several confidential services are available:

Safe to Talk: 0800 044 334 (or text 4334)
Male Survivors Aotearoa: Find your local centre here
National Office for Professional Standards: 0800 114 622
Society of Mary Confidential Helpline: 021 909 749